Marcelo Gleiser |
WILL WE EVER KNOW?--Recently NPR’s
science blog 13.7 cosmos & culture posed such questions in a remarkable
essay by Marcelo Gleiser. It can be
read by linking to: http://www.npr.org/blogs/13.7/2013/03/20/174729853/where-did-life-come-from-the-mind-the-universe-can-we-even-know?utm_source=NPR&utm_medium=facebook&utm_campaign=20130320
Obviously the universe has
an origin: Gleiser’s blog mulls whether we’ll ever get to the bottom of it is
the question.
An excerpt: “…The first point in common is that not so
long ago these three questions were not considered scientific. On the contrary,
the origin of the Universe, of life, and of mind were thought to be the result
of divine work, products of supernatural intervention. Which god or gods were
responsible depended (and still does to the vast majority of the world
population) on your particular faith. Differences aside, in any religion only
an entity that transcended space and time could create the cosmos, which exists
within space and time; only an immortal entity had the power to create life;
and only an omniscient power could endow His creatures with intelligence and a
sense of being.
The confrontation with natural processes is
immediate: Nature is within space and time, living entities are not immortal
and no one is — or can be — omniscient. (Although the World Wide Web, allied
with global human intelligence and powerful search engines, could, in some
sense, be called a proto-omniscient entity. Stuff for another week.)
For this reason, it is not at all surprising that
scientists encounter such resistance when they state that they are near — or at
least making progress — in answering such questions without recourse to divine
intervention. According to the scientific viewpoint, the origins of the cosmos,
of life and of mind are natural processes that obey material laws and
principles. Their complexity and our current lack of answers do not mean that
such questions are completely beyond the reach of science, or that such
questions can only be addressed through religious belief. In science, ignorance
is the pre-condition to knowledge; to not-know is the pathway to knowing…”
Gleiser offers the following “Short
Reading List On The Three Origins”:
1. Cosmos
The Origin of the Universe,
by John Barrow
Big Bang: The Origin of the
Universe, by Simon Singh
A Universe From Nothing:
Why There Is Something Rather Than Nothing, by Lawrence Krauss
The First Three Minutes: A
Modern View of the Origin of the Universe, by Steven Weinberg
The Dancing Universe: From
Creation Myths to the Big Bang, by Marcelo Gleiser
2. Life
Origins of Life, by Freeman
Dyson
Seven Clues to the Origin
of Life: A Scientific Detective Story, by A. G. Cairns-Smith
The Fifth Miracle: The
Search for the Origin and Meaning of Life, by Paul Davies
Emergence of Life on Earth:
A Historical and Scientific Overview, by Iris Fry
Life's Origin: The
Beginnings of Biological Evolution, J. William Schopf, ed.
3. Mind
Origin of Mind: Evolution
of Brain, Cognition, and General Intelligence, by David C. Geary
Astonishing Hypothesis: The
Scientific Search for the Soul, by Francis Crick
The Age of Insight: The
Quest to Understand the Unconscious in Art, Mind, and Brain, from Vienna 1900
to the Present, by Eric Kandel
How the Mind Works, by
Steven Pinker
Self Comes to Mind:
Constructing the Conscious Brain, by Antonio Damasio
You can keep up with more
of what Marcelo is thinking on Facebook and Twitter: @mgleiser
No comments:
Post a Comment