|  | 
| Nice quote, nice picture but Ring Lardner never said it. The quote is most often credited to Damon Runyon, but he never said it either. The quote was originally penned by sportswriter Huge E. Keogh. | 
SOME LIKE THEM COLD
Short Story By Ring Lardner, published 1924.
N. Y., Aug. 3. 
Dear Miss Gillespie: How about our bet now as you 
bet me I would forget all about you the minute I hit the big 
town and would never write you a letter. Well girlie it looks 
like you lose so pay me. Seriously we will call all bets off as I 
am not the kind that bet on a sure thing and it sure was a sure 
thing that I would not forget a girlie like you and all that is 
worrying me is whether it may not be the other way round 
and you are wondering who this fresh guy is that is writeing 
you this letter. I bet you are so will try and refreshen your 
memory. 
Well girlie I am the handsome young man that was won- 
dering round the Lasalle st. station Monday and "happened" 
to sit down beside of a mighty pretty girlie who was waiting to 
meet her sister from Toledo and the train was late and I am 
glad of it because if it had not of been that little girlie and I 
would never of met. So for once I was a lucky guy but still I 
guess it was time I had some luck as it was certainly tough luck 
for you and I to both be liveing in Chi all that time and never 
get together till a half hour before I was leaveing town for 
good. 
Still "better late than never" you know and maybe we can 
make up for lost time though it looks like we would have to do 
our makeing up at long distants unless you make good on your 
threat and come to N.Y. I wish you would do that little thing 
girlie as it looks like that was the only way we would get a 
chance to play round together as it looks like they was little or 
no chance of me comeing back to Chi as my whole future is in 
the big town. N.Y. is the only spot and specially for a man that 
expects to make my liveing in the song writeing game as here is 
the Mecca for that line of work and no matter how good a man 
may be they don't get no recognition unless they live in N.Y. 
Well girlie you asked me to tell you all about my trip. Well I 
remember you saying that you would give anything to be 
makeing it yourself but as far as the trip itself was conserned 
you ought to be thankfull you did not have to make it as you 
would of sweat your head off. I know I did specially wile going 
through Ind. Monday p. m. but Monday night was the worst of 
all trying to sleep and finely I give it up and just layed there 
with the prespiration rolling off of me though I was laying on 
top of the covers and nothing on but my underwear. 
Yesterday was not so bad as it rained most of the a. m. come- 
ing through N.Y. state and in the p. m. we road along side of 
the Hudson all p. m. Some river girlie and just looking at it 
makes a man forget all about the heat and everything else ex- 
cept a certain girlie who I seen for the first time Monday and 
then only for a half hour but she is the kind of a girlie that a 
man don't need to see her only once and they would be no 
danger of forgetting her. There I guess I better lay off that 
subject or you will think I am a "fresh guy." 
Well that is about all to tell you about the trip only they was 
one amuseing incidence that come off yesterday which I will 
tell you. Well they was a dame got on the train at Toledo Mon- 
day and had the birth opp. mine but I did not see nothing of 
her that night as I was out smokeing till late and she hit the hay 
early but yesterday A. m. she come in the dinner and sit at the 
same table with me and tried to make me and it was so raw 
that the dinge waiter seen it and give me the wink and of 
course I paid no tension and I waited till she got through so as 
thev would be no danger of her foiling me out but she stopped 
on the way out to get a tooth pick and when I come out she 
was out on the platform with it so I tried to brush right by but 
she spoke up and asked me what time it was and I told her and 
she said she geussed her watch was slow so I said maybe it just 
seemed slow on acct. of the company it was in. 
way she give up trying to make me and got off at Albany. She 
was a good looker but I have no time for gals that tries to make 
strangers on a train. 
Well if I don't quit you will think I am writeing a book but 
will expect a long letter in answer to this letter and we will 
see if you can keep your promise like I have kept mine. Don't 
dissapoint me girlie as I am all alone in a large city and hear- 
ing from you will keep me from getting home sick for old Chi 
though I never thought so much of the old town till I found out 
you lived there. Don't think that is kidding girlie as I mean it. 
You can address me at this hotel as it looks like I will be here 
right along as it is on 47ty st. right off of old Broadway and 
handy to everything and am only paying $21 per wk. for my 
rm. and could of got one for $16 but without bath but am glad 
to pay the differents as am lost without my bath in the A. M. 
and sometimes at night too. 
Tomorrow I expect to commence fighting the "battle of 
Broadway" and will let you know how I come out that is if you 
answer this letter. In the mean wile girlie au reservoir and 
don't do nothing I would not do. 
Your new friend (?) 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111,, Aug. 6. 
My Dear Mr. Lewis: Well, that certainly was a "surprise 
party" getting your letter and you are certainly a "wonder 
man" to keep your word as I am afraid most men of your sex 
are gay deceivers but maybe you are "different." Any way it 
sure was a surprise and will gladly pay the bet if you will just 
tell me what it was we bet. Hope it was not money as I am a 
"working girl" but if it was not more than a dollar or two will 
try to dig it up even if I have to "beg, borrow or steal." 
Suppose you will think me a "case" to make a bet and then 
forget what it was, but you must remember, Mr. Man, that I 
had just met you and was "dazzled." Joking aside I was rather 
"fussed" and will tell you why. Well, Mr. Lewis, I suppose you 
see lots of girls like the one you told me about that you saw on 
the train who tried to "get acquainted" but I want to assure 
you that I am not one of those kind and sincerely hope you will 
believe me when I tell you that you was the first man I ever 
spoke to meeting them like that and my friends and the people 
who know me would simply faint if they knew I ever spoke to 
a man without a "proper introduction." 
Believe me, Mr. Lewis, I am not that kind and I don't know 
now why I did it only that you was so "different" looking if you 
know what I mean and not at all like the kind of men that 
usually try to force their attentions on every pretty girl they 
see. Lots of times I act on impulse and let my feelings run away 
from me and sometimes I do things on the impulse of the mo- 
ment which I regret them later on, and that is what I did this 
time, but hope you won't give me cause to regret it and I know 
you won't as I know you are not that kind of a man a specially 
after what you told me about the girl on the train. But any way 
as I say, I was in a "daze" so can't remember what it was we 
bet, but will try and pay it if it does not "break" me. 
Sis's train got in about ten minutes after yours had gone and 
when she saw me what do you think was the first thing she 
said? Well, Mr. Lewis, she said: "Why Mibs (That is a pet 
name some of my friends have given me ) what has happened 
to you? I never seen you have as much color." So I passed it off 
with some remark about the heat and changed the subject as I 
certainly was not going to tell her that I had just been talking 
to a man who I had never met or she would of dropped dead 
from the shock. Either that or she would not of believed me as 
it would be hard for a person who knows me well to imagine 
me doing a thing like that as I have quite a reputation for 
"squelching" men who try to act fresh. I don't mean anything 
personal by that, Mr. Lewis, as am a good judge of character 
and could tell without you telling me that you are not that 
kind. 
Well, Sis and I have been on the "go" ever since she arrived 
as I took yesterday and today off so I could show her the 
"sights" though she says she would be perfectly satisfied to 
just sit in the apartment and listen to me "rattle on." Am afraid 
I am a great talker, Mr. Lewis, but Sis says it is as good as a 
show to hear me talk as I tell things in such a different way 
as I cannot help from seeing the humorous side of everything 
and she says she never gets tired of listening to me, but of 
course she is my sister and thinks the world of me, but she 
really does laugh like she enjoyed my craziness. 
Maybe I told you that I have a tiny little apartment which a 
girl friend of mine and I have together and it is hardly big 
enough to turn round in, but still it is "home" and I am a great 
home girl and hardly ever care to go out evenings except occa- 
sionally to the theatre or dance. But even if our "nest" is small 
we are proud of it and Sis complimented us on how cozy it is 
and how "homey" it looks and she said she did not see how we 
could afford to have everything so nice and Edith (my girl 
friend) said: "Mibs deserves all the credit for that. I never 
knew a girl who could make a little money go a long ways like 
she can." Well, of course she is my best friend and always say- 
ing nice things about me, but I do try and I hope I get results. 
Have always said that good taste and being careful is a whole 
lot more important than lots of money though it is nice to 
have it. 
You must write and tell me how you are getting along in the 
"battle of Broadway" (I laughed when I read that) and 
whether the publishers like your songs though I know they 
will. Am crazy to hear them and hear you play the piano as 
I love good jazz music even better than classical, though I sup- 
pose it is terrible to say such a thing. But I usually say just 
what I think though sometimes I wish afterwards I had not of. 
But still I believe it is better for a girl to be her own self and 
natural instead of always acting. But am afraid I will never 
have a chance to hear you play unless you come back to Chi 
and pay us a visit as my "threat" to come to New York was just 
a "threat" and I don't see any hope of ever getting there unless 
some rich New Yorker should fall in love with me and take me 
there to live. Fine chance for poor little me, eh Mr. Lewis? 
Well, I guess I have "rattled on" long enough and you will 
think I am writing a book unless I quit and besides, Sis has 
asked me as a special favor to make her a pie for dinner. Maybe 
you don't know it, Mr. Man, but I am quite famous for my pie 
and pastry, but I don't suppose a "genius" is interested in 
common things like that. 
Well, be sure and write soon and tell me what N.Y. is like 
and all about it and don't forget the little girlie who was "bad" 
and spoke to a strange man in the station and have been blush- 
ing over it ever since. 
Your friend (?) 
Mabelle Gillespie. 
Dear Girlie: I bet you will think I am a fresh guy com- 
menceing that way but Miss Gillespie is too cold and a man 
can not do nothing cold in this kind of weather specially in this 
man's town which is the hottest place I ever been in and I guess 
maybe the reason why New Yorkers is so bad is because they 
think they are all ready in H and can not go no worse 
place no matter how they behave themselves. Honest girlie I 
certainly envy you being where there is a breeze off the old 
Lake and Chi mav be dirty but I never heard of nobody dying 
because thev was dirtv but four people died here yesterday on 
acct. of the heat and I seen two different women flop right on 
Broadway and had to be taken away in the ambulance and it 
could not of been because they was dressed too warm because 
it would be impossible for the women here to leave off any 
more cloths. 
Well have not had much luck yet in the battle of Broadway 
as all the heads of the big music publishers is out of town on 
their vacation and the big boys is the only ones I will do busi- 
ness with as it would be silly for a man with the stuff I have got 
to waste my time on somebody that is just on the staff and have 
not got the final say. But I did play a couple of my numbers for 
the people up to Levy's and Goebers and they went crazy over 
them in both places. So it looks like all I have to do is wait for 
the big boys to get back and then play my numbers for them 
and I will be all set. What I want is to get taken on the staff of 
one of the big firms as that gives a man the inside and they will 
plug your numbers more if you are on the staff. In the mean 
wile have not got nothing to worry me but am just seeing the 
sights of the big town as have saved up enough money to play 
round for a wile and any way a man that can play piano like I 
can don't never have to worry about starveing. Can certainly 
make the old music box talk girlie and am always good for a 
$75 or $100 job. 
Well have been here a week now and on the go every minute 
and I thought I would be lonesome down here but no chance 
of that as I have been treated fine by the people I have met 
and have sure met a bunch of them. One of the boys liveing in 
the hotel is a vaudeville actor and he is a member of the Friars 
club and took me over there to dinner the other night and some 
way another the bunch got wise that I could play piano so of 
course I had to sit down and give them some of my numbers 
and everybody went crazy over them. One of the boys I met 
there was Paul Sears the song writer but he just writes the 
lyrics and has wrote a bunch of hits and when he heard some 
of my melodies he called me over to one side and said he would 
like to work with me on some numbers. How is that girlie as he 
is one of the biggest hit writers in N.Y. 
N.Y. has got some mighty pretty girlies and I guess it would 
not be hard to get acquainted with them and in fact several of 
them has tried to make me since I been here but I always fig- 
ure that a girl must be something wrong with her if she tries 
to make a man that she don't know nothing about so I pass 
them all up. But I did meet a couple of pips that a man here 
in the hotel went up on Riverside Drive to see them and in- 
sisted on me going along and they got on some way that I 
could make a piano talk so they was nothing but I must play 
for them so I sit down and played some of my own stuff and 
they went crazy over it. 
One of the girls wanted I should come up and see her again, 
and I said I might but I think I better keep away as she acted 
like she wanted to vamp me and I am not the kind that likes to 
play round with a gal just for their company and dance with 
them etc. but when I see the right gal that will be a different 
thing and she won't have to beg me to come and see her as I 
will camp right on her trail till she says yes. And it won't be 
none of these N.Y. fly by nights neither. They are all right to 
look at but a man would be a sucker to get serious with them as 
they might take you up and the next thing you know you would 
have a wife on your hands that don't know a dish rag from a 
waffle iron. 
Well girlie will quit and call it a day as it is too hot to write 
any more and I guess I will turn on the cold water and lay in 
the tub a wile and then turn in. Don't forget to write to 
Your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Dear Mr. Man: Hope you won't think me a "silly Billy" for 
starting my letter that way but "Mr. Lewis" is so formal and 
"Charles" is too much the other way and any way I would not 
dare call a man by their first name after only knowing them 
only two weeks. Though I may as well confess that Charles is 
my favorite name for a man and have always been crazy about 
it as it was my father's name. Poor old dad, he died of cancer 
three years ago, but left enough insurance so that mother and 
we girls were well provided for and do not have to do any- 
thing to support ourselves though I have been earning my own 
living for two years to make things easier for mother and also 
because I simply can't bear to be doing nothing as I feel like a 
"drone." So I flew away from the "home nest" though mother 
felt bad about it as I was her favorite and she always said I was 
such a comfort to her as when I was in the house she never 
had to worry about how things would go. 
But there I go gossiping about my domestic affairs just like 
you would be interested in them though I don't see how you 
could be though personly I always like to know all about my 
friends, but I know men are different so will try and not bore 
you any longer. Poor Man, I certainly feel sorry for you if New 
York is as hot as all that. I guess it has been very hot in Chi, 
too, at least everybody has been complaining about how 
terrible it is. Suppose you will wonder why I say "I guess" and 
you will think I ought to know if it is hot. Well, sir, the reason 
I say "I guess" is because I don't feel the heat like others do or 
at least I don't let myself feel it. That sounds crazy I know, but 
don't you think there is a good deal in mental suggestion and 
not letting yourself feel things? I believe that if a person 
simply won't allow themselves to be affected by disagreeable 
things, why such things won't bother them near as much. I 
know it works with me and that is the reason why I am never 
cross when things go wrong and "keep smiling" no matter 
what happens and as far as the heat is concerned, why I just 
don't let myself feel it and my friends say I don't even look hot 
no matter if the weather is boiling and Edith, my girl friend, 
often says that I am like a breeze and it cools her off just to 
have me come in the room. Poor Edie suffers terribly during 
the hot weather and says it almost makes her mad at me to 
see how cool and unruffled I look when everybody else is per- 
spiring and have red faces etc. 
I laughed when I read what you said about New York being 
so hot that people thought it was the "other place." I can ap- 
preciate a joke, Mr. Man, and that one did not go "over my 
head/' Am still laughing at some of the things you said in the 
station though they probably struck me funnier than they 
would most girls as I always see the funny side and sometimes 
something is said and I laugh and the others wonder what I am 
laughing at as they cannot see anything in it themselves, but 
it is just the way I look at things so of course I cannot explain 
to them why I laughed and they think I am crazy. But I had 
rather part with almost anything rather than my sense of hu- 
mour as it helps me over a great many rough spots. 
Sis has gone back home though I would of liked to of kept 
her here much longer, but she had to go though she said she 
would of liked nothing better than to stay with me and just 
listen to me "rattle on." She always says it is just like a show 
to hear me talk as I always put things in such a funny way and 
for weeks after she has been visiting me she thinks of some of 
the things I said and laughs over them. Since she left Edith 
and I have been pretty quiet though poor Edie wants to be on 
the "go" all the time and tries to make me go out with her every 
evening to the pictures and scolds me when I say I had rather 
stay home and read and calls me a "book worm." Well, it is true 
that I had rather stay home with a good book than go to some 
crazy old picture and the last two nights I have been reading 
myself to sleep with Robert W. Service's poems. Don't you 
love Service or don't you care for "highbrow" writings? 
Personly there is nothing I love more than to just sit and 
read a good book or sit and listen to somebody play the piano, 
and I mean if they can really play and I really believe I like pop- 
ular music better than the classical though I suppose that is a 
terrible thing to confess, but I love all kinds of music but a 
speciallv the piano when it is played by somebody who can 
really play. 
Am glad you have not "fallen" for the "ladies" who have 
tried to make your acquaintance in New York. You are right 
in thinking there must be something wrong with girls who try 
to "pick up" strange men as no girl with self respect would do 
such a thing and when I say that, Mr. Man, I know you will 
think it is a funny thing for me to say on account of the way our 
friendship started, but I mean it and I assure you that was the 
first time I ever done such a thing in my life and would never 
of thought of doing it had I not known you were the right kind 
of a man as I flatter myself that I am a good judge of character 
and can tell pretty well what a person is like by just looking at 
them and I assure you I had made up my mind what kind of a 
man you were before I allowed myself to answer your opening 
remark. Otherwise I am the last girl in the world that would 
allow myself to speak to a person without being introduced to 
them. 
on Riverside Drive and what she looks like and if you went to 
see her again and all about her. Suppose you will think I am 
a little old "curiosity shop" for asking all those questions and 
will wonder why I want to know. Well, sir, I won't tell you 
why, so there, but I insist on you answering all questions and 
will scold you if you don't. Maybe you will think the reason 
why I am so curious is because I am "jealous" of the lady in 
question. Well, sir, I won't tell you whether I am or not, but 
will keep you "guessing." Now, don't you wish you knew? 
Must close or you will think I am going to "rattle on" for- 
ever or maybe you have all ready become disgusted and torn 
my letter up. If so all I can say is poor little me — she was a nice 
little girl and meant well, but the man did not appreciate her. 
There! Will stop or you will think I am crazy if you do not 
all ready. 
Yours (?) 
Maybelle. 
N. Y., Aug. 20. 
Dear Girlie: Well girlie I suppose you thought I was 
never going to answer your letter but have been busier than a 
one armed paper hanger the last week as have been working 
on a number with Paul Sears who is one of the best lyric 
writers in N.Y. and has turned out as many hits as Berlin or 
Davis or any of them. And believe me girlie he has turned out 
another hit this time that is he and I have done it together. It 
is all done now and we are just waiting for the best chance to 
place it but will not place it nowheres unless we get the right 
kind of a deal but maybe will publish it ourselves. 
The song is bound to go over big as Sears has wrote a great 
lyric and I have give it a great tune or at least every body that 
has heard it goes crazy over it and it looks like it would go over 
bigger than any song since Mammy and would not be sur- 
prised to see it come out the hit of the year. If it is handled 
right we will make a bbl. of money and Sears says it is a cinch 
we will clean up as much as $25000 apiece which is pretty fair 
for one song but this one is not like the most of them but has 
got a great lyric and I have wrote a melody that will knock 
them out of their seats. I only wish you could hear it girlie and 
hear it the way I play it. I had to play it over and over about 
50 times at the Friars last night. 
I will copy down the lyric of the chorus so you can see what 
it is like and get the idea of the song though of course you can't 
tell much about it unless you hear it played and sang. The title 
of the song is When They're Like You and here is the chorus : 
"Some like them hot, some like them cold. 
Some like them when they're not too darn old. 
Some like them fat, some like them lean. 
Some like them only at sweet sixteen. 
Some like them dark, some like them light. 
Some like them in the park, late at night. 
Some like them fickle, some like them true, 
But the time I like them is when they're like you." 
How is that for a lyric and I only wish I could play my mel- 
ody for you as you would go nuts over it but will send you a 
copy as soon as the song is published and you can get some of 
your friends to play it over for you and I know you will like it 
though it is a different melody when I play it or when some- 
body else plays it. 
Well girlie you will see how busy I have been and am libel 
to keep right on being busy as we are not going to let the grass 
grow under our feet but as soon as we have got this number 
placed we will get busy on another one as a couple like that 
will put me on Easy st. even if they don't go as big as we expect 
but even 25 grand is a big bunch of money and if a man could 
only turn out one hit a year and make that much out of it I 
would be on Easy st. and no more hammering on the old music 
box in some cabaret. 
Who ever we take the song to we will make them come 
across with one grand for advance royaltys and that will keep 
me going till I can turn out another one. So the future looks 
bright and rosey to yours truly and I am certainly glad I come 
to the big town though sorry I did not do it a whole lot quicker. 
This is a great old town girlie and when you have lived here 
a wile you wonder how you ever stood for a burg like Chi 
which is just a hick town along side of this besides being dirty 
etc. and a man is a sucker to stay there all their life specially a 
man in my line of work as N.Y. is the Mecca for a man that has 
got the musical gift. I figure that all the time I spent in Chi I 
was just wasteing my time and never really started to live till 
I come down here and I have to laugh when I think of the boys 
out there that is trying to make a liveing in the song writeing 
game and most of them starve to death all their life and the 
first week I am down here I meet a man like Sears and the next 
thing you know we have turned out a song that will make us a 
fortune. 
|  | 
| Circa 1922 at the White House with (left to right): President Warren Harding; Grantland Rice, Ring Lardner and Under Secretary of State, Henry Fletcher. | 
Well girlie you asked me to tell you about the girlie up on
the Drive that tried to make me and asked me to come and 
see her again. Well I can assure you you have no reasons to be 
jealous in that quarter as I have not been back to see her as I 
figure it is wasteing my time to play round with a dame like 
she that wants to go out somewheres every night and if you 
married her she would want a house on 5th ave. with a dozen 
servants so I have passed her up as that is not my idea of home. 
What I want when I get married is a real home where a man 
can stay home and work and maybe have a few of his friends 
in once in a wile and entertain them or go to a good musical 
show once in a wile and have a wife that is in sympathy with 
you and not nag at you all the wile but be a real help mate. The 
girlie up on the Drive would run me ragged and have me in 
the poor house inside of a year even if I was makeing 25 grand 
out of one song. Besides she wears a make up that you would 
have to blast to find out what her face looks like. So I have not 
been back there and don't intend to see her again so what is 
the use of me telling you about her. And the only other girlie 
I have met is a sister of Paul Sears who I met up to his house 
wile we was working on the song but she don't hardly count 
as she has not got no use for the boys but treats them like dirt 
and Paul says she is the coldest proposition he ever seen. 
Well I don't know no more to write and besides have £ot a 
date to go out to Paul's place for dinner and play some of my 
stuff for him so as he can see if he wants to set words to some 
more of my melodies. Well don't do nothing I would not do 
and have as good a time as you can in old Chi and will let you 
know how we come along with the song. 
Chas. F. Lewis 
Chicago, 111., Aug. 23. 
Dear Mr. Man: I am thrilled to death over the song and 
think the words awfully pretty and am crazy to hear the music 
which I know must be great. It must be wonderful to have the 
gift of writing songs and then hear people play and sing them 
and just think of making $25,000 in such a short time. My, how 
rich you will be and I certainly congratulate you though am 
afraid when you are rich and famous you will have no time 
for insignificant little me or will you be an exception and re- 
member your "old" friends even when you are up in the world? 
I sincerely hope so. 
Will look forward to receiving a copy of the song and will 
you be sure and put your name on it? I am all ready very con- 
ceited just to think that I know a man that writes songs and 
makes all that money. 
Seriously I wish you success with your next song and I 
laughed when I read your remark about being busier than a 
one armed paper hanger. I don't see how you think up all those 
comparisons and crazy things to say. The next time one of the 
girls asks me to go out with them I am going to tell them I can't 
go because I am busier than a one armed paper hanger and 
then they will think I made it up and say: "The girl is clever/' 
Seriously I am glad you did not go back to see the girl on 
the Drive and am also glad you don't like girls who makes 
themselves up so much as I think it is disgusting and would 
rather go round looking like a ghost than put artificial color 
on my face. Fortunately I have a complexion that does not 
need "fixing" but even if my coloring was not what it is I would 
never think of lowering myself to "fix" it. But I must tell you a 
joke that happened just the other day when Edith and I were 
out at lunch and there was another girl in the restaurant whom 
Edie knew and she introduced her to me and I noticed how 
this girl kept staring at me and finally she begged my pardon 
and asked if she could ask me a personal question and I said 
yes and she asked me if my complexion was really "mine." I 
assured her it was and she said: "Well, I thought so because 
I did not think anybody could put it on so artistically. I cer- 
tainly envy you." Edie and I both laughed. 
Well, if that girl envies me my complexion, why I envy you 
living in New York. Chicago is rather dirty though I don't let 
that part of it bother me as I bathe and change my clothing so 
often that the dirt does not have time to "settle." Edie often 
says she cannot see how I always keep so clean looking and 
says I always look like I had just stepped out of a band box. 
She also calls me a fish (jokingly) because I spend so much 
time in the water. But seriously I do love to bathe and never 
feel so happy as when I have just "cleaned up" and put on 
fresh clothing. 
Edie has just gone out to see a picture and was cross at me 
because I would not go with her. I told her I was going to write 
a letter and she wanted to know to whom and I told her and 
she said: "You write to him so often that a person would almost 
think you was in love with him." I just laughed and turned it 
off, but she does say the most embarrassing things and I would 
be angry if it was anybody but she that said them. 
Seriously I had much rather sit here and write letters or read 
or just sit and dream than go out to some crazy old picture 
show except once in awhile I do like to go to the theater and 
see a good play and a specially a musical play if the music is 
catchy. But as a rule I am contented to just stay home and feel 
cozy and lots of evenings Edie and I sit here without saying 
hardly a word to each other though she would love to talk but 
she knows I had rather be quiet and she often says it is just like 
living with a deaf and dumb mute to live with me because I 
make so little noise round the apartment. I guess I was born to 
be a home body as I so seldom care to go "gadding." 
Though I do love to have company once in awhile, just a 
few congenial friends whom I can talk to and feel at home 
with and play cards or have some music. My friends love to 
drop in here, too, as they say Edie and I always give them 
such nice things to eat. Though poor Edie has not much to do 
with it, I am afraid, as she hates anything connected with 
cooking which is one of the things I love best of anything and 
I often say that when I begin keeping house in my own home 
I will insist on doing most of my own work as I would take so 
much more interest in it than a servant, though I would want 
somebody to help me a little if I could afford it as I often think 
a woman that does all her own work is liable to get so tired that 
she loses interest in the bigger things of life like books and 
music. Though after all what bigger thing is there than home 
making a specially for a woman? 
I am sitting in the dearest old chair that I bought yesterday 
at a little store on the North Side. That is my one extravagance, 
buying furniture and things for the house, but I always say it 
is economy in the long run as I will always have them and have 
use for them and when I can pick them up at a bargain I would 
be silly not to. Though heaven knows I will never be "poor" 
in regards to furniture and rugs and things like that as 
mother's house in Toledo is full of lovely things which she says 
she is going to give to Sis and myself as soon as we have real 
homes of our own. She is going to give me the first choice as I 
am her favorite. She has the loveliest old things that you could 
not buy now for love or money including lovely old rugs and a 
piano which Sis wanted to have a player attachment put on it 
but I said it would be an insult to the piano so we did not get 
one. I am funny about things like that, a specially old furniture 
and feel towards them like people whom I love. 
Poor mother, I am afraid she won't live much longer to enjoy 
her lovely old things as she has been suffering for years from 
stomach trouble and the doctor says it has been worse lately 
instead of better and her heart is weak besides. I am going 
home to see her a few days this fall as it may be the last time. 
She is very cheerful and always says she is ready to go now as 
she has had enough joy out of life and all she would like would 
be to see her girls settled down in their own homes before she 
goes. 
There I go, talking about my domestic affairs again and I 
will bet you are bored to death though personly I am never 
bored when my friends tell me about themselves. But I won't 
"rattle on" any longer, but will say good night and don't forget 
to write and tell me how you come out with the song and 
thanks for sending me the words to it. Will you write a song 
about me some time? I would be thrilled to death! But I am 
afraid I am not the kind of girl that inspires men to write songs 
about them, but am just a quiet "mouse" that loves home and 
am not giddy enough to be the heroine of a song. 
Well, Mr. Man, good night and don't wait so long before 
writing again to 
Yours (?) 
Mabelle. 
|  | 
| Yardley won a Pulitzer Prize for Criticism, 1981, this paper back was published in 2001 | 
N. Y, Sept. 8.
Dear Girlie: Well girlie have not got your last letter with 
me so cannot answer what was in it as I have forgotten if there 
was anything I was supposed to answer and besides have only 
a little time to write as I have a date to go out on a party with 
the Sears. We are going to the Georgie White show and after- 
wards somewheres for supper. Sears is the boy who wrote the 
lyric to my song and it is him and his sister I am going on the 
party with. The sister is a cold fish that has no use for men but 
she is show crazy and insists on Paul takeing her to 3 or 4 of 
them a week. 
Paul wants me to give up my room here and come and live 
with them as they have plenty of room and I am running a 
little low on money but don't know if I will do it or not as am 
afraid I would freeze to death in the same house with a girl 
like the sister as she is ice cold but she don't hang round the 
house much as she is always takeing trips or going to shows or 
somewheres. 
So far we have not had no luck with the song. All the pub- 
lishers we have showed it to has went crazy over it but they 
won't make the right kind of a deal with us and if they don't 
loosen up and give us a decent royalty rate we are libel to put 
the song out ourselves and show them up. The man up to 
Goebel's told us the song was O.K. and he liked it but it was 
more of a production number than anything else and ought to 
go in a show like the Follies but they won't be in N.Y. much 
longer and what we ought to do is hold it till next spring. 
Mean wile I am working on some new numbers and also 
have taken a position with the orchestra at the Wilton and am 
going to work there starting next week. They pay good money 
$60 and it will keep me going. 
Well girlie that is about all the news. I believe you said your 
father was sick and hope he is better and also hope you are 
getting along O.K. and take care of yourself. When you have 
nothing else to do write to your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111., Sept. 11. 
Dear Mr. Lewis: Your short note reached me yesterday 
and must say I was puzzled when I read it. It sounded like 
you was mad at me though I cannot think of any reason why 
you should be. If there was something I said in my last letter 
that offended you I wish you would tell me what it was and I 
will ask your pardon though I cannot remember anything I 
could of said that you could take offense at. But if there was 
something, why I assure you, Mr. Lewis, that I did not mean 
anything by it. I certainly did not intend to offend you in any 
way. 
Perhaps it is nothing I wrote you, but you are worried on 
account of the publishers not treating you fair in regards to 
your song and that is why your letter sounded so distant. If 
that is the case I hope that by this time matters have rectified 
themselves and the future looks brighter. But any way, Mr. 
Lewis, don't allow yourself to worry over business cares as 
they will all come right in the end and I always think it is silly 
for people to worry themselves sick over temporary troubles, 
but the best way is to "keep smiling" and look for the "silver 
lining" in the cloud. That is the way I always do and no matter 
what happens, I manage to smile and my girl friend, Edie, 
calls me Sunny because I always look on the bright side. 
Remember also, Mr. Lewis, that $60 is a salary that a great 
many men would like to be getting and are living on less than 
that and supporting a wife and family on it. I always say that 
a person can get along on whatever amount they make if they 
manage things in the right way. 
So if it is business troubles, Mr. Lewis, I say don't worry, 
but look on the bright side. But if it is something I wrote in my 
last letter that offended you I wish you would tell me what it 
was so I can apologize as I assure you I meant nothing and 
would not say anything to hurt you for the world. 
Please let me hear from you soon as I will not feel comfort- 
able until I know I am not to blame for the sudden change. 
Sincerely, 
Mabelle Gillespie. 
N. Y., Sept. 24. 
Dear Miss Gillespie: Just a few lines to tell you the big 
news or at least it is big news to me. I am engaged to be mar- 
ried to Paul Sears' sister and we are going to be married early 
next month and live in Atlantic City where the orchestra I 
have been playing with has got an engagement in one of the 
big cabarets. 
I know this will be a surprise to you as it was even a surprise 
to me as I did not think I would ever have the nerve to ask the 
girlie the big question as she was always so cold and acted like 
I was just in the way. But she said she supposed she would have 
to marry somebody some time and she did not dislike me as 
much as most of the other men her brother brought round and 
she would marry me with the understanding that she would 
not have to be a slave and work round the house and also I 
would have to take her to a show or somewheres every night 
and if I could not take her mvself she would "run wild" alone. 
Atlantic City will be O.K. for that as a lot of new shows opens 
down there and she will be able to see them before they get to 
the big town. As for her being: a slave, I would hate to think of 
marrying a girl and then have them spend their lives in drug- 
o;erv round the house. We are going to live in a hotel till we 
find something better but will be in no hurry to start house 
keeping as we will have to buy all new furniture. 
Betsy is some doll when she is all fixed up and believe me 
she knows how to fix herself up. I don't know what she uses 
but it is weather proof as I have been out in a rain storm with 
her and we both got drowned but her face stayed on. I would 
almost think it was real only she tells me different. 
Well girlie I may write to you again once in a wile as Betsy 
says she don't give a dam if I write to all the girls in the world 
just so I don't make her read the answers but that is all I can 
think of to say now except good bye and good luck and may 
the right man come along soon and he will be a lucky man 
getting a girl that is such a good cook and got all that furniture 
etc. 
But just let me give you a word of advice before I close and 
that is don't never speak to strange men who you don't know 
nothing about as they may get you wrong and think you are 
trying to make them. It just happened that I knew better so 
you was lucky in my case but the luck might not last. 
Your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111., Sept. 27. 
My Dear Mr. Lewis: Thanks for your advice and also 
thank your fiance for her generosity in allowing you to con- 
tinue your correspondence with her "rivals," but personly I 
have no desire to take advantage of that generosity as I have 
something better to do than read letters from a man like you, 
a specially as I have a man friend who is not so generous as 
Miss Sears and would strongly object to my continuing a cor- 
respondence with another man. It is at his request that I am 
writing this note to tell you not to expect to hear from me 
again. 
Allow me to congratulate you on your engagement to Miss 
Sears and I am sure she is to be congratulated too, though if 
I met the lady I would be tempted to ask her to tell me her 
secret, namely how is she going to "run wild" on $60. 
Sincerely, 
Mabelle Gillespie. 
-->
-->
SUNDAY REVIEW / RING LARDNER’S PATOIS 
SOME LIKE THEM COLD
By Ring Lardner
N. Y., Aug. 3. 
Dear Miss Gillespie: How about our bet now as you 
bet me I would forget all about you the minute I hit the big 
town and would never write you a letter. Well girlie it looks 
like you lose so pay me. Seriously we will call all bets off as I 
am not the kind that bet on a sure thing and it sure was a sure 
thing that I would not forget a girlie like you and all that is 
worrying me is whether it may not be the other way round 
and you are wondering who this fresh guy is that is writeing 
you this letter. I bet you are so will try and refreshen your 
memory. 
Well girlie I am the handsome young man that was won- 
dering round the Lasalle st. station Monday and "happened" 
to sit down beside of a mighty pretty girlie who was waiting to 
meet her sister from Toledo and the train was late and I am 
glad of it because if it had not of been that little girlie and I 
would never of met. So for once I was a lucky guy but still I 
guess it was time I had some luck as it was certainly tough luck 
for you and I to both be liveing in Chi all that time and never 
get together till a half hour before I was leaveing town for 
good. 
Still "better late than never" you know and maybe we can 
make up for lost time though it looks like we would have to do 
our makeing up at long distants unless you make good on your 
threat and come to N.Y. I wish you would do that little thing 
girlie as it looks like that was the only way we would get a 
chance to play round together as it looks like they was little or 
no chance of me comeing back to Chi as my whole future is in 
the big town. N.Y. is the only spot and specially for a man that 
expects to make my liveing in the song writeing game as here is 
the Mecca for that line of work and no matter how good a man 
may be they don't get no recognition unless they live in N.Y. 
Well girlie you asked me to tell you all about my trip. Well I 
remember you saying that you would give anything to be 
makeing it yourself but as far as the trip itself was conserned 
you ought to be thankfull you did not have to make it as you 
would of sweat your head off. I know I did specially wile going 
through Ind. Monday p. m. but Monday night was the worst of 
all trying to sleep and finely I give it up and just layed there 
with the prespiration rolling off of me though I was laying on 
top of the covers and nothing on but my underwear. 
Yesterday was not so bad as it rained most of the a. m. come- 
ing through N.Y. state and in the p. m. we road along side of 
the Hudson all p. m. Some river girlie and just looking at it 
makes a man forget all about the heat and everything else ex- 
cept a certain girlie who I seen for the first time Monday and 
then only for a half hour but she is the kind of a girlie that a 
man don't need to see her only once and they would be no 
danger of forgetting her. There I guess I better lay off that 
subject or you will think I am a "fresh guy." 
Well that is about all to tell you about the trip only they was 
one amuseing incidence that come off yesterday which I will 
tell you. Well they was a dame got on the train at Toledo Mon- 
day and had the birth opp. mine but I did not see nothing of 
her that night as I was out smokeing till late and she hit the hay 
early but yesterday A. m. she come in the dinner and sit at the 
same table with me and tried to make me and it was so raw 
that the dinge waiter seen it and give me the wink and of 
course I paid no tension and I waited till she got through so as 
thev would be no danger of her foiling me out but she stopped 
on the way out to get a tooth pick and when I come out she 
was out on the platform with it so I tried to brush right by but 
she spoke up and asked me what time it was and I told her and 
she said she geussed her watch was slow so I said maybe it just 
seemed slow on acct. of the company it was in. 
I don't know if she got what I was driveing at or not but any 
way she give up trying to make me and got off at Albany. She 
was a good looker but I have no time for gals that tries to make 
strangers on a train. 
Well if I don't quit you will think I am writeing a book but 
will expect a long letter in answer to this letter and we will 
see if you can keep your promise like I have kept mine. Don't 
dissapoint me girlie as I am all alone in a large city and hear- 
ing from you will keep me from getting home sick for old Chi 
though I never thought so much of the old town till I found out 
you lived there. Don't think that is kidding girlie as I mean it. 
You can address me at this hotel as it looks like I will be here 
right along as it is on 47ty st. right off of old Broadway and 
handy to everything and am only paying $21 per wk. for my 
rm. and could of got one for $16 but without bath but am glad 
to pay the differents as am lost without my bath in the A. M. 
and sometimes at night too. 
Tomorrow I expect to commence fighting the "battle of 
Broadway" and will let you know how I come out that is if you 
answer this letter. In the mean wile girlie au reservoir and 
don't do nothing I would not do. 
Your new friend (?) 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111,, Aug. 6. 
My Dear Mr. Lewis: Well, that certainly was a "surprise 
party" getting your letter and you are certainly a "wonder 
man" to keep your word as I am afraid most men of your sex 
are gay deceivers but maybe you are "different." Any way it 
sure was a surprise and will gladly pay the bet if you will just 
tell me what it was we bet. Hope it was not money as I am a 
"working girl" but if it was not more than a dollar or two will 
try to dig it up even if I have to "beg, borrow or steal." 
Suppose you will think me a "case" to make a bet and then 
forget what it was, but you must remember, Mr. Man, that I 
had just met you and was "dazzled." Joking aside I was rather 
"fussed" and will tell you why. Well, Mr. Lewis, I suppose you 
see lots of girls like the one you told me about that you saw on 
the train who tried to "get acquainted" but I want to assure 
you that I am not one of those kind and sincerely hope you will 
believe me when I tell you that you was the first man I ever 
spoke to meeting them like that and my friends and the people 
who know me would simply faint if they knew I ever spoke to 
a man without a "proper introduction." 
Believe me, Mr. Lewis, I am not that kind and I don't know 
now why I did it only that you was so "different" looking if you 
know what I mean and not at all like the kind of men that 
usually try to force their attentions on every pretty girl they 
see. Lots of times I act on impulse and let my feelings run away 
from me and sometimes I do things on the impulse of the mo- 
ment which I regret them later on, and that is what I did this 
time, but hope you won't give me cause to regret it and I know 
you won't as I know you are not that kind of a man a specially 
after what you told me about the girl on the train. But any way 
as I say, I was in a "daze" so can't remember what it was we 
bet, but will try and pay it if it does not "break" me. 
Sis's train got in about ten minutes after yours had gone and 
when she saw me what do you think was the first thing she 
said? Well, Mr. Lewis, she said: "Why Mibs (That is a pet 
name some of my friends have given me ) what has happened 
to you? I never seen you have as much color." So I passed it off 
with some remark about the heat and changed the subject as I 
certainly was not going to tell her that I had just been talking 
to a man who I had never met or she would of dropped dead 
from the shock. Either that or she would not of believed me as 
it would be hard for a person who knows me well to imagine 
me doing a thing like that as I have quite a reputation for 
"squelching" men who try to act fresh. I don't mean anything 
personal by that, Mr. Lewis, as am a good judge of character 
and could tell without you telling me that you are not that 
kind. 
Well, Sis and I have been on the "go" ever since she arrived 
as I took yesterday and today off so I could show her the 
"sights" though she says she would be perfectly satisfied to 
just sit in the apartment and listen to me "rattle on." Am afraid 
I am a great talker, Mr. Lewis, but Sis says it is as good as a 
show to hear me talk as I tell things in such a different way 
as I cannot help from seeing the humorous side of everything 
and she says she never gets tired of listening to me, but of 
course she is my sister and thinks the world of me, but she 
really does laugh like she enjoyed my craziness. 
Maybe I told you that I have a tiny little apartment which a 
girl friend of mine and I have together and it is hardly big 
enough to turn round in, but still it is "home" and I am a great 
home girl and hardly ever care to go out evenings except occa- 
sionally to the theatre or dance. But even if our "nest" is small 
we are proud of it and Sis complimented us on how cozy it is 
and how "homey" it looks and she said she did not see how we 
could afford to have everything so nice and Edith (my girl 
friend) said: "Mibs deserves all the credit for that. I never 
knew a girl who could make a little money go a long ways like 
she can." Well, of course she is my best friend and always say- 
ing nice things about me, but I do try and I hope I get results. 
Have always said that good taste and being careful is a whole 
lot more important than lots of money though it is nice to 
have it. 
You must write and tell me how you are getting along in the 
"battle of Broadway" (I laughed when I read that) and 
whether the publishers like your songs though I know they 
will. Am crazy to hear them and hear you play the piano as 
I love good jazz music even better than classical, though I sup- 
pose it is terrible to say such a thing. But I usually say just 
what I think though sometimes I wish afterwards I had not of. 
But still I believe it is better for a girl to be her own self and 
natural instead of always acting. But am afraid I will never 
have a chance to hear you play unless you come back to Chi 
and pay us a visit as my "threat" to come to New York was just 
a "threat" and I don't see any hope of ever getting there unless 
some rich New Yorker should fall in love with me and take me 
there to live. Fine chance for poor little me, eh Mr. Lewis? 
Well, I guess I have "rattled on" long enough and you will 
think I am writing a book unless I quit and besides, Sis has 
asked me as a special favor to make her a pie for dinner. Maybe 
you don't know it, Mr. Man, but I am quite famous for my pie 
and pastry, but I don't suppose a "genius" is interested in 
common things like that. 
Well, be sure and write soon and tell me what N.Y. is like 
and all about it and don't forget the little girlie who was "bad" 
and spoke to a strange man in the station and have been blush- 
ing over it ever since. 
Your friend (?) 
Mabelle Gillespie. 
N. Y., Aug. 10. 
Dear Girlie: I bet you will think I am a fresh guy com- 
menceing that way but Miss Gillespie is too cold and a man 
can not do nothing cold in this kind of weather specially in this 
man's town which is the hottest place I ever been in and I guess 
maybe the reason why New Yorkers is so bad is because they 
think they are all ready in H and can not go no worse 
place no matter how they behave themselves. Honest girlie I 
certainly envy you being where there is a breeze off the old 
Lake and Chi mav be dirty but I never heard of nobody dying 
because thev was dirtv but four people died here yesterday on 
acct. of the heat and I seen two different women flop right on 
Broadway and had to be taken away in the ambulance and it 
could not of been because they was dressed too warm because 
it would be impossible for the women here to leave off any 
more cloths. 
Well have not had much luck yet in the battle of Broadway 
as all the heads of the big music publishers is out of town on 
their vacation and the big boys is the only ones I will do busi- 
ness with as it would be silly for a man with the stuff I have got 
to waste my time on somebody that is just on the staff and have 
not got the final say. But I did play a couple of my numbers for 
the people up to Levy's and Goebers and they went crazy over 
them in both places. So it looks like all I have to do is wait for 
the big boys to get back and then play my numbers for them 
and I will be all set. What I want is to get taken on the staff of 
one of the big firms as that gives a man the inside and they will 
plug your numbers more if you are on the staff. In the mean 
wile have not got nothing to worry me but am just seeing the 
sights of the big town as have saved up enough money to play 
round for a wile and any way a man that can play piano like I 
can don't never have to worry about starveing. Can certainly 
make the old music box talk girlie and am always good for a 
$75 or $100 job. 
Well have been here a week now and on the go every minute 
and I thought I would be lonesome down here but no chance 
of that as I have been treated fine by the people I have met 
and have sure met a bunch of them. One of the boys liveing in 
the hotel is a vaudeville actor and he is a member of the Friars 
club and took me over there to dinner the other night and some 
way another the bunch got wise that I could play piano so of 
course I had to sit down and give them some of my numbers 
and everybody went crazy over them. One of the boys I met 
there was Paul Sears the song writer but he just writes the 
lyrics and has wrote a bunch of hits and when he heard some 
of my melodies he called me over to one side and said he would 
like to work with me on some numbers. How is that girlie as he 
is one of the biggest hit writers in N.Y. 
N.Y. has got some mighty pretty girlies and I guess it would 
not be hard to get acquainted with them and in fact several of 
them has tried to make me since I been here but I always fig- 
ure that a girl must be something wrong with her if she tries 
to make a man that she don't know nothing about so I pass 
them all up. But I did meet a couple of pips that a man here 
in the hotel went up on Riverside Drive to see them and in- 
sisted on me going along and they got on some way that I 
could make a piano talk so they was nothing but I must play 
for them so I sit down and played some of my own stuff and 
they went crazy over it. 
One of the girls wanted I should come up and see her again, 
and I said I might but I think I better keep away as she acted 
like she wanted to vamp me and I am not the kind that likes to 
play round with a gal just for their company and dance with 
them etc. but when I see the right gal that will be a different 
thing and she won't have to beg me to come and see her as I 
will camp right on her trail till she says yes. And it won't be 
none of these N.Y. fly by nights neither. They are all right to 
look at but a man would be a sucker to get serious with them as 
they might take you up and the next thing you know you would 
have a wife on your hands that don't know a dish rag from a 
waffle iron. 
Well girlie will quit and call it a day as it is too hot to write 
any more and I guess I will turn on the cold water and lay in 
the tub a wile and then turn in. Don't forget to write to 
Your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Dear Mr. Man: Hope you won't think me a "silly Billy" for 
starting my letter that way but "Mr. Lewis" is so formal and 
"Charles" is too much the other way and any way I would not 
dare call a man by their first name after only knowing them 
only two weeks. Though I may as well confess that Charles is 
my favorite name for a man and have always been crazy about 
it as it was my father's name. Poor old dad, he died of cancer 
three years ago, but left enough insurance so that mother and 
we girls were well provided for and do not have to do any- 
thing to support ourselves though I have been earning my own 
living for two years to make things easier for mother and also 
because I simply can't bear to be doing nothing as I feel like a 
"drone." So I flew away from the "home nest" though mother 
felt bad about it as I was her favorite and she always said I was 
such a comfort to her as when I was in the house she never 
had to worry about how things would go. 
But there I go gossiping about my domestic affairs just like 
you would be interested in them though I don't see how you 
could be though personly I always like to know all about my 
friends, but I know men are different so will try and not bore 
you any longer. Poor Man, I certainly feel sorry for you if New 
York is as hot as all that. I guess it has been very hot in Chi, 
too, at least everybody has been complaining about how 
terrible it is. Suppose you will wonder why I say "I guess" and 
you will think I ought to know if it is hot. Well, sir, the reason 
I say "I guess" is because I don't feel the heat like others do or 
at least I don't let myself feel it. That sounds crazy I know, but 
don't you think there is a good deal in mental suggestion and 
not letting yourself feel things? I believe that if a person 
simply won't allow themselves to be affected by disagreeable 
things, why such things won't bother them near as much. I 
know it works with me and that is the reason why I am never 
cross when things go wrong and "keep smiling" no matter 
what happens and as far as the heat is concerned, why I just 
don't let myself feel it and my friends say I don't even look hot 
no matter if the weather is boiling and Edith, my girl friend, 
often says that I am like a breeze and it cools her off just to 
have me come in the room. Poor Edie suffers terribly during 
the hot weather and says it almost makes her mad at me to 
see how cool and unruffled I look when everybody else is per- 
spiring and have red faces etc. 
I laughed when I read what you said about New York being 
so hot that people thought it was the "other place." I can ap- 
preciate a joke, Mr. Man, and that one did not go "over my 
head/' Am still laughing at some of the things you said in the 
station though they probably struck me funnier than they 
would most girls as I always see the funny side and sometimes 
something is said and I laugh and the others wonder what I am 
laughing at as they cannot see anything in it themselves, but 
it is just the way I look at things so of course I cannot explain 
to them why I laughed and they think I am crazy. But I had 
rather part with almost anything rather than my sense of hu- 
mour as it helps me over a great many rough spots. 
Sis has gone back home though I would of liked to of kept 
her here much longer, but she had to go though she said she 
would of liked nothing better than to stay with me and just 
listen to me "rattle on." She always says it is just like a show 
to hear me talk as I always put things in such a funny way and 
for weeks after she has been visiting me she thinks of some of 
the things I said and laughs over them. Since she left Edith 
and I have been pretty quiet though poor Edie wants to be on 
the "go" all the time and tries to make me go out with her every 
evening to the pictures and scolds me when I say I had rather 
stay home and read and calls me a "book worm." Well, it is true 
that I had rather stay home with a good book than go to some 
crazy old picture and the last two nights I have been reading 
myself to sleep with Robert W. Service's poems. Don't you 
love Service or don't you care for "highbrow" writings? 
Personly there is nothing I love more than to just sit and 
read a good book or sit and listen to somebody play the piano, 
and I mean if they can really play and I really believe I like pop- 
ular music better than the classical though I suppose that is a 
terrible thing to confess, but I love all kinds of music but a 
speciallv the piano when it is played by somebody who can 
really play. 
Am glad you have not "fallen" for the "ladies" who have 
tried to make your acquaintance in New York. You are right 
in thinking there must be something wrong with girls who try 
to "pick up" strange men as no girl with self respect would do 
such a thing and when I say that, Mr. Man, I know you will 
think it is a funny thing for me to say on account of the way our 
friendship started, but I mean it and I assure you that was the 
first time I ever done such a thing in my life and would never 
of thought of doing it had I not known you were the right kind 
of a man as I flatter myself that I am a good judge of character 
and can tell pretty well what a person is like by just looking at 
them and I assure you I had made up my mind what kind of a 
man you were before I allowed myself to answer your opening 
remark. Otherwise I am the last girl in the world that would 
allow myself to speak to a person without being introduced to 
them. 
When you write again you must tell me all about the girl 
on Riverside Drive and what she looks like and if you went to 
see her again and all about her. Suppose you will think I am 
a little old "curiosity shop" for asking all those questions and 
will wonder why I want to know. Well, sir, I won't tell you 
why, so there, but I insist on you answering all questions and 
will scold you if you don't. Maybe you will think the reason 
why I am so curious is because I am "jealous" of the lady in 
question. Well, sir, I won't tell you whether I am or not, but 
will keep you "guessing." Now, don't you wish you knew? 
Must close or you will think I am going to "rattle on" for- 
ever or maybe you have all ready become disgusted and torn 
my letter up. If so all I can say is poor little me — she was a nice 
little girl and meant well, but the man did not appreciate her. 
There! Will stop or you will think I am crazy if you do not 
all ready. 
Yours (?) 
Maybelle. 
N. Y., Aug. 20. 
Dear Girlie: Well girlie I suppose you thought I was 
never going to answer your letter but have been busier than a 
one armed paper hanger the last week as have been working 
on a number with Paul Sears who is one of the best lyric 
writers in N.Y. and has turned out as many hits as Berlin or 
Davis or any of them. And believe me girlie he has turned out 
another hit this time that is he and I have done it together. It 
is all done now and we are just waiting for the best chance to 
place it but will not place it nowheres unless we get the right 
kind of a deal but maybe will publish it ourselves. 
The song is bound to go over big as Sears has wrote a great 
lyric and I have give it a great tune or at least every body that 
has heard it goes crazy over it and it looks like it would go over 
bigger than any song since Mammy and would not be sur- 
prised to see it come out the hit of the year. If it is handled 
right we will make a bbl. of money and Sears says it is a cinch 
we will clean up as much as $25000 apiece which is pretty fair 
for one song but this one is not like the most of them but has 
got a great lyric and I have wrote a melody that will knock 
them out of their seats. I only wish you could hear it girlie and 
hear it the way I play it. I had to play it over and over about 
50 times at the Friars last night. 
I will copy down the lyric of the chorus so you can see what 
it is like and get the idea of the song though of course you can't 
tell much about it unless you hear it played and sang. The title 
of the song is When They're Like You and here is the chorus : 
"Some like them hot, some like them cold. 
Some like them when they're not too darn old. 
Some like them fat, some like them lean. 
Some like them only at sweet sixteen. 
Some like them dark, some like them light. 
Some like them in the park, late at night. 
Some like them fickle, some like them true, 
But the time I like them is when they're like you." 
How is that for a lyric and I only wish I could play my mel- 
ody for you as you would go nuts over it but will send you a 
copy as soon as the song is published and you can get some of 
your friends to play it over for you and I know you will like it 
though it is a different melody when I play it or when some- 
body else plays it. 
Well girlie you will see how busy I have been and am libel 
to keep right on being busy as we are not going to let the grass 
grow under our feet but as soon as we have got this number 
placed we will get busy on another one as a couple like that 
will put me on Easy st. even if they don't go as big as we expect 
but even 25 grand is a big bunch of money and if a man could 
only turn out one hit a year and make that much out of it I 
would be on Easy st. and no more hammering on the old music 
box in some cabaret. 
Who ever we take the song to we will make them come 
across with one grand for advance royaltys and that will keep 
me going till I can turn out another one. So the future looks 
bright and rosey to yours truly and I am certainly glad I come 
to the big town though sorry I did not do it a whole lot quicker. 
This is a great old town girlie and when you have lived here 
a wile you wonder how you ever stood for a burg like Chi 
which is just a hick town along side of this besides being dirty 
etc. and a man is a sucker to stay there all their life specially a 
man in my line of work as N.Y. is the Mecca for a man that has 
got the musical gift. I figure that all the time I spent in Chi I 
was just wasteing my time and never really started to live till 
I come down here and I have to laugh when I think of the boys 
out there that is trying to make a liveing in the song writeing 
game and most of them starve to death all their life and the 
first week I am down here I meet a man like Sears and the next 
thing you know we have turned out a song that will make us a 
fortune. 
Well girlie you asked me to tell you about the girlie up on 
the Drive that tried to make me and asked me to come and 
see her again. Well I can assure you you have no reasons to be 
jealous in that quarter as I have not been back to see her as I 
figure it is wasteing my time to play round with a dame like 
she that wants to go out somewheres every night and if you 
married her she would want a house on 5th ave. with a dozen 
servants so I have passed her up as that is not my idea of home. 
What I want when I get married is a real home where a man 
can stay home and work and maybe have a few of his friends 
in once in a wile and entertain them or go to a good musical 
show once in a wile and have a wife that is in sympathy with 
you and not nag at you all the wile but be a real help mate. The 
girlie up on the Drive would run me ragged and have me in 
the poor house inside of a year even if I was makeing 25 grand 
out of one song. Besides she wears a make up that you would 
have to blast to find out what her face looks like. So I have not 
been back there and don't intend to see her again so what is 
the use of me telling you about her. And the only other girlie 
I have met is a sister of Paul Sears who I met up to his house 
wile we was working on the song but she don't hardly count 
as she has not got no use for the boys but treats them like dirt 
and Paul says she is the coldest proposition he ever seen. 
Well I don't know no more to write and besides have £ot a 
date to go out to Paul's place for dinner and play some of my 
stuff for him so as he can see if he wants to set words to some 
more of my melodies. Well don't do nothing I would not do 
and have as good a time as you can in old Chi and will let you 
know how we come along with the song. 
Chas. F. Lewis 
Chicago, 111., Aug. 23. 
Dear Mr. Man: I am thrilled to death over the song and 
think the words awfully pretty and am crazy to hear the music 
which I know must be great. It must be wonderful to have the 
gift of writing songs and then hear people play and sing them 
and just think of making $25,000 in such a short time. My, how 
rich you will be and I certainly congratulate you though am 
afraid when you are rich and famous you will have no time 
for insignificant little me or will you be an exception and re- 
member your "old" friends even when you are up in the world? 
I sincerely hope so. 
Will look forward to receiving a copy of the song and will 
you be sure and put your name on it? I am all ready very con- 
ceited just to think that I know a man that writes songs and 
makes all that money. 
Seriously I wish you success with your next song and I 
laughed when I read your remark about being busier than a 
one armed paper hanger. I don't see how you think up all those 
comparisons and crazy things to say. The next time one of the 
girls asks me to go out with them I am going to tell them I can't 
go because I am busier than a one armed paper hanger and 
then they will think I made it up and say: "The girl is clever/' 
Seriously I am glad you did not go back to see the girl on 
the Drive and am also glad you don't like girls who makes 
themselves up so much as I think it is disgusting and would 
rather go round looking like a ghost than put artificial color 
on my face. Fortunately I have a complexion that does not 
need "fixing" but even if my coloring was not what it is I would 
never think of lowering myself to "fix" it. But I must tell you a 
joke that happened just the other day when Edith and I were 
out at lunch and there was another girl in the restaurant whom 
Edie knew and she introduced her to me and I noticed how 
this girl kept staring at me and finally she begged my pardon 
and asked if she could ask me a personal question and I said 
yes and she asked me if my complexion was really "mine." I 
assured her it was and she said: "Well, I thought so because 
I did not think anybody could put it on so artistically. I cer- 
tainly envy you." Edie and I both laughed. 
Well, if that girl envies me my complexion, why I envy you 
living in New York. Chicago is rather dirty though I don't let 
that part of it bother me as I bathe and change my clothing so 
often that the dirt does not have time to "settle." Edie often 
says she cannot see how I always keep so clean looking and 
says I always look like I had just stepped out of a band box. 
She also calls me a fish (jokingly) because I spend so much 
time in the water. But seriously I do love to bathe and never 
feel so happy as when I have just "cleaned up" and put on 
fresh clothing. 
Edie has just gone out to see a picture and was cross at me 
because I would not go with her. I told her I was going to write 
a letter and she wanted to know to whom and I told her and 
she said: "You write to him so often that a person would almost 
think you was in love with him." I just laughed and turned it 
off, but she does say the most embarrassing things and I would 
be angry if it was anybody but she that said them. 
Seriously I had much rather sit here and write letters or read 
or just sit and dream than go out to some crazy old picture 
show except once in awhile I do like to go to the theater and 
see a good play and a specially a musical play if the music is 
catchy. But as a rule I am contented to just stay home and feel 
cozy and lots of evenings Edie and I sit here without saying 
hardly a word to each other though she would love to talk but 
she knows I had rather be quiet and she often says it is just like 
living with a deaf and dumb mute to live with me because I 
make so little noise round the apartment. I guess I was born to 
be a home body as I so seldom care to go "gadding." 
Though I do love to have company once in awhile, just a 
few congenial friends whom I can talk to and feel at home 
with and play cards or have some music. My friends love to 
drop in here, too, as they say Edie and I always give them 
such nice things to eat. Though poor Edie has not much to do 
with it, I am afraid, as she hates anything connected with 
cooking which is one of the things I love best of anything and 
I often say that when I begin keeping house in my own home 
I will insist on doing most of my own work as I would take so 
much more interest in it than a servant, though I would want 
somebody to help me a little if I could afford it as I often think 
a woman that does all her own work is liable to get so tired that 
she loses interest in the bigger things of life like books and 
music. Though after all what bigger thing is there than home 
making a specially for a woman? 
I am sitting in the dearest old chair that I bought yesterday 
at a little store on the North Side. That is my one extravagance, 
buying furniture and things for the house, but I always say it 
is economy in the long run as I will always have them and have 
use for them and when I can pick them up at a bargain I would 
be silly not to. Though heaven knows I will never be "poor" 
in regards to furniture and rugs and things like that as 
mother's house in Toledo is full of lovely things which she says 
she is going to give to Sis and myself as soon as we have real 
homes of our own. She is going to give me the first choice as I 
am her favorite. She has the loveliest old things that you could 
not buy now for love or money including lovely old rugs and a 
piano which Sis wanted to have a player attachment put on it 
but I said it would be an insult to the piano so we did not get 
one. I am funny about things like that, a specially old furniture 
and feel towards them like people whom I love. 
Poor mother, I am afraid she won't live much longer to enjoy 
her lovely old things as she has been suffering for years from 
stomach trouble and the doctor says it has been worse lately 
instead of better and her heart is weak besides. I am going 
home to see her a few days this fall as it may be the last time. 
She is very cheerful and always says she is ready to go now as 
she has had enough joy out of life and all she would like would 
be to see her girls settled down in their own homes before she 
goes. 
There I go, talking about my domestic affairs again and I 
will bet you are bored to death though personly I am never 
bored when my friends tell me about themselves. But I won't 
"rattle on" any longer, but will say good night and don't forget 
to write and tell me how you come out with the song and 
thanks for sending me the words to it. Will you write a song 
about me some time? I would be thrilled to death! But I am 
afraid I am not the kind of girl that inspires men to write songs 
about them, but am just a quiet "mouse" that loves home and 
am not giddy enough to be the heroine of a song. 
Well, Mr. Man, good night and don't wait so long before 
writing again to 
Yours (?) 
Mabelle. 
N. Y, Sept. 8. 
Dear Girlie: Well girlie have not got your last letter with 
me so cannot answer what was in it as I have forgotten if there 
was anything I was supposed to answer and besides have only 
a little time to write as I have a date to go out on a party with 
the Sears. We are going to the Georgie White show and after- 
wards somewheres for supper. Sears is the boy who wrote the 
lyric to my song and it is him and his sister I am going on the 
party with. The sister is a cold fish that has no use for men but 
she is show crazy and insists on Paul takeing her to 3 or 4 of 
them a week. 
Paul wants me to give up my room here and come and live 
with them as they have plenty of room and I am running a 
little low on money but don't know if I will do it or not as am 
afraid I would freeze to death in the same house with a girl 
like the sister as she is ice cold but she don't hang round the 
house much as she is always takeing trips or going to shows or 
somewheres. 
So far we have not had no luck with the song. All the pub- 
lishers we have showed it to has went crazy over it but they 
won't make the right kind of a deal with us and if they don't 
loosen up and give us a decent royalty rate we are libel to put 
the song out ourselves and show them up. The man up to 
Goebel's told us the song was O.K. and he liked it but it was 
more of a production number than anything else and ought to 
go in a show like the Follies but they won't be in N.Y. much 
longer and what we ought to do is hold it till next spring. 
Mean wile I am working on some new numbers and also 
have taken a position with the orchestra at the Wilton and am 
going to work there starting next week. They pay good money 
$60 and it will keep me going. 
Well girlie that is about all the news. I believe you said your 
father was sick and hope he is better and also hope you are 
getting along O.K. and take care of yourself. When you have 
nothing else to do write to your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111., Sept. 11. 
Dear Mr. Lewis: Your short note reached me yesterday 
and must say I was puzzled when I read it. It sounded like 
you was mad at me though I cannot think of any reason why 
you should be. If there was something I said in my last letter 
that offended you I wish you would tell me what it was and I 
will ask your pardon though I cannot remember anything I 
could of said that you could take offense at. But if there was 
something, why I assure you, Mr. Lewis, that I did not mean 
anything by it. I certainly did not intend to offend you in any 
way. 
Perhaps it is nothing I wrote you, but you are worried on 
account of the publishers not treating you fair in regards to 
your song and that is why your letter sounded so distant. If 
that is the case I hope that by this time matters have rectified 
themselves and the future looks brighter. But any way, Mr. 
Lewis, don't allow yourself to worry over business cares as 
they will all come right in the end and I always think it is silly 
for people to worry themselves sick over temporary troubles, 
but the best way is to "keep smiling" and look for the "silver 
lining" in the cloud. That is the way I always do and no matter 
what happens, I manage to smile and my girl friend, Edie, 
calls me Sunny because I always look on the bright side. 
Remember also, Mr. Lewis, that $60 is a salary that a great 
many men would like to be getting and are living on less than 
that and supporting a wife and family on it. I always say that 
a person can get along on whatever amount they make if they 
manage things in the right way. 
So if it is business troubles, Mr. Lewis, I say don't worry, 
but look on the bright side. But if it is something I wrote in my 
last letter that offended you I wish you would tell me what it 
was so I can apologize as I assure you I meant nothing and 
would not say anything to hurt you for the world. 
Please let me hear from you soon as I will not feel comfort- 
able until I know I am not to blame for the sudden change. 
Sincerely, 
Mabelle Gillespie. 
N. Y., Sept. 24. 
Dear Miss Gillespie: Just a few lines to tell you the big 
news or at least it is big news to me. I am engaged to be mar- 
ried to Paul Sears' sister and we are going to be married early 
next month and live in Atlantic City where the orchestra I 
have been playing with has got an engagement in one of the 
big cabarets. 
I know this will be a surprise to you as it was even a surprise 
to me as I did not think I would ever have the nerve to ask the 
girlie the big question as she was always so cold and acted like 
I was just in the way. But she said she supposed she would have 
to marry somebody some time and she did not dislike me as 
much as most of the other men her brother brought round and 
she would marry me with the understanding that she would 
not have to be a slave and work round the house and also I 
would have to take her to a show or somewheres every night 
and if I could not take her mvself she would "run wild" alone. 
Atlantic City will be O.K. for that as a lot of new shows opens 
down there and she will be able to see them before they get to 
the big town. As for her being: a slave, I would hate to think of 
marrying a girl and then have them spend their lives in drug- 
o;erv round the house. We are going to live in a hotel till we 
find something better but will be in no hurry to start house 
keeping as we will have to buy all new furniture. 
Betsy is some doll when she is all fixed up and believe me 
she knows how to fix herself up. I don't know what she uses 
but it is weather proof as I have been out in a rain storm with 
her and we both got drowned but her face stayed on. I would 
almost think it was real only she tells me different. 
Well girlie I may write to you again once in a wile as Betsy 
says she don't give a dam if I write to all the girls in the world 
just so I don't make her read the answers but that is all I can 
think of to say now except good bye and good luck and may 
the right man come along soon and he will be a lucky man 
getting a girl that is such a good cook and got all that furniture 
etc. 
But just let me give you a word of advice before I close and 
that is don't never speak to strange men who you don't know 
nothing about as they may get you wrong and think you are 
trying to make them. It just happened that I knew better so 
you was lucky in my case but the luck might not last. 
Your friend, 
Chas. F. Lewis. 
Chicago, 111., Sept. 27. 
My Dear Mr. Lewis: Thanks for your advice and also 
thank your fiance for her generosity in allowing you to con- 
tinue your correspondence with her "rivals," but personly I 
have no desire to take advantage of that generosity as I have 
something better to do than read letters from a man like you, 
a specially as I have a man friend who is not so generous as 
Miss Sears and would strongly object to my continuing a cor- 
respondence with another man. It is at his request that I am 
writing this note to tell you not to expect to hear from me 
again. 
Allow me to congratulate you on your engagement to Miss 
Sears and I am sure she is to be congratulated too, though if 
I met the lady I would be tempted to ask her to tell me her 
secret, namely how is she going to "run wild" on $60. 
Sincerely, 
Mabelle Gillespie. 



 
 
No comments:
Post a Comment