![]() |
We think PBS missed one. The existing Hallidie Building in San Francisco, 1917 was more influential to future generations because of its original use of glass as a building facade. |
RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE--PBS started the discussion on “Ten Buildings That
Changed America” by airing a recent documentary the nation’s most influential
buildings.

Being American, where
everyone gets one vote, Pillar to Post (P2P) happily takes up the one-person challenge
and offers up the following roster, which differs significantly from what PBS
broadcast.
Who wins? Who cares? It’s
only a debate. PBS is listed first
followed by P2P’s counter offer.
PBS: Virginia State Capitol
building, 1788. Architect: Thomas
Jefferson
PILLAR TO POST: Independence
Hall, 1732-53, Philadelphia, Edmund Wooley and Andrew Hamilton with steeple
design by William Strickland. Why?
Karma. Slave labor not an issue in
Philadelphia.
PBS: Trinity Church,
Boston, 1877. Henry Hobson Richardson
P2P: California Tower, San
Diego, 1915, Bertrand Goodhue. Why? America never embraced Richardson’s style
after his death, however, Goodhue’s Mediterranean style adapted well to
residential Spanish Revival and remains a period tour de force today.
PBS: Wainright Building,
St. Louis, 1891, Louis Sullivan
P2P: Hallidie Building, San
Francisco, 1917, Willis Polk. Why? Polk’s glass high rise exterior predates Mies
vander Rohe et al by two generations.
PBS: Robie House, Chicago, 1910,
Frank Lloyd Wright
P2P: Gamble House, Pasadena, CA, 1908, Charles and
Henry Greene. Why? Sheer numbers: America embraced more of
Greene’s Arts & Crafts bungalow styles compared with Wright’s Prairie
vernacular.
PBS: Ford Motor Company
plant, Highland Park, Michigan, 1910, Albert Kahn
P2P: Kennedy Space Center
Buildings, Merrit Island, FL, 1965, Charles Luckman. Why?
Cars vs stars.
PBS: Southdale Shopping Center, near Minneapolis,
Victor Gruen
P2P: Schlesinger & Mayer Department Store,
1872, Louis Sullivan. Why? Changed America’s retail shopping methods a
century before suburban malls.
PBS: Seagram Building, New
York, City, 1958, Ludwig Mies vander Rohe
P2P: Agree. Seagram Building is the most solid
pick, however, kudos to the United Nations Building, New York City, 1947-53 by
Le Corbusier and Oscar Niemeyer, Howard Robertson with Harrison and Abramovitz
architects.
PBS: Dulles Airport, Near
Washington DC, 1962, Eero Saarinen
P2P: Salk Institute, La Jolla CA, 1959, Louis Kahn. Why?
Form and function. Kahn is
timeless, while Saarinen and Gehry will be the Gaudi of their day.
PBS: Vanna Venturi Philadelphia
Residence, 1964, Robert Venturi
P2P: Kaufman Residence,
Fallingwater, Western Pennsylvania, 1938, Frank Lloyd Wright
PBS: Walk Disney Concert Hall,
Los Angeles, 2003, Frank Gehry
P2P: LA International
Airport theme building, 1961, Charles Luckman.
Why? Luckman among the first to bend the lines. Luckman’s statement is
about the limitless future, while Gehry is saying I can do what I want.
No comments:
Post a Comment